Judicial Accountability: A Comparative Note on India and Malaysia
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
India and Malaysia are the countries having similar characteristics of the political system. The self-governed model of Judicial Accountability has been given impetus importance in Malaysia contrary to the Indian legal system. The Judicial Standards and Accountability Bill 2012 being a replica of the Judges Enquiry (Amendment) Bill 2005, has been pending before the Parliament for many years. On the other hand, the Malaysian legal system adopted the judicial standards way back in 1986. Inordinate delay on the part of the Indian legal system seems to be a major setback for the image of the biggest democratic country. The severe allegations against judges of the Supreme Court of India and High Courts and aborted efforts of the Parliament in ensuring judicial accountability have inspired the author to take up a comparative study of the topic. The paper starts with a cursory view of the judicial system in India and Malaysia followed by a conceptual analysis of judicial accountability. It outlines the status of judicial accountability as contemplated under the constitutional and legal framework of both countries. It concludes by identifying the similarities, dissimilarities, and best practices of both systems in the context of ideal practices required for judicial accountability.
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
References
ABA Canons of Judicial Ethics, 1924
ABA Model Code of Judicial Conduct 2010
African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights (27 June 1981, entered into force 21 October 1986) OAU Doc OAU/LEG/EXP/AFCHPR/PROT(III)
AJ Harding, 'The 1988 Constitutional Crisis in Malaysia' (1990) 39 International and Comparative Law Quarterly 57-81 <https://doi.org/10.1093/iclqaj/39.1.57>
Alexander Hamilton, James Madison and John Jay, The Federalist Papers (New American Library 1961) <https://archive.org/details/federalistpapers1961hami>
American Bar Association, 'Model Code of Judicial Conduct' (2020) Canon 1 (2020) canon 1 <https://www.americanbar.org/groups/professional_responsibility/publications/model_code_of_judicial_conduct/>
American Convention on Human Rights (adopted 22 November 1969, entered into force 18 July 1978) 1144 UNTS 123
Arthur T Vanderbilt, The Doctrine of the Separation of Powers and Its Present-Day Significance (University of Nebraska Press 1953) <https://archive.org/details/doctrineofsepara0000vand>
Asok Mukhopadhyay, 'Administrative Accountability : A Conceptual Analysis' (1983) 29 Indian Journal of Public Administration 473-487 <https://doi.org/10.1177/0019556119830304>
Azahar bin Mohamed, 'Court Reform Programmes: The Malaysian Experience' [2015] 102 Amicus Curiae 15-24 <https://doi.org/10.14296/ac.v2015i102.2432>
Bangalore Principles of Judicial Conduct 2002
Basic Principles on the Independence of the Judiciary, 1985
Beijing Statement of Principles of the Independence of the Judiciary, 1985
Benjamin N Cardozo, Nature of the Judicial Process (Yale University Press 1921) <https://archive.org/details/NatureOfTheJudicialProcess>
Bruce LR Smith and DC Hague (eds), 'Accountability and Independence in the Contract State' in The Dilemma of Accountability in Modern Government: Independence Versus Control (St Martin's Press 1971)
Code of Conduct for United States Judges 1973
Colin Scott, 'Accountability in the Regulatory State' (2000) 27 Journal of Law and Society 38-60 <https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-6478.00146>
Constitution of Albania 1998
Constitution of Algeria 2020
Constitution of Barbados 1966
Constitution of Barbados 2002
Constitution of Egypt 2014
Constitution of Eritrea 1997
Constitution of Gambia 2019
Constitution of India 1950
Constitution of Kenya 2010
Constitution of Libya 2016
Constitution of Marshall Islands, 1979
Constitution of Mauritania, 1991
Constitution of Mauritius 1968
Constitution of Mexico 1917
Constitution of Monaco 1962
Constitution of Mongolia 1992
Constitution of Montenegro 2007
Constitution of Morocco 2011
Constitution of Mozambique 2004
Constitution of Myanmar 2008
Constitution of Namibia 1990
Constitution of Nauru 1968
Constitution of Nicaragua 1987
Constitution of Nigeria 1999
Constitution of Norway 1814
Constitution of Oman 1996
Constitution of Pakistan 1973
Constitution of Republic of Moldova 1994
Contempt of Court Act 1971 (India)
Convention on the Rights of the Child (adopted 20 November 1989, entered into force 2 September 1990) 1577 UNTS 3
Courts of Judicature Act 1964
D Rangaswamy, 'Judicial Accountability in India: Issues and Challenges' (2020) 2 International Journal of Governance and Public Policy Analysis 67-89 <https://journals.sjp.ac.lk/index.php/ijgppa/article/view/4800>
David Lyons, Ethics and the Rule of Law (Cambridge University Press 1983) <https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511608933>
Defamation Act 1957
Ernest L Sakala, 'The Accountability of the Judiciary: Accountability to Whom? Is There Such a Mechanism?' (2005) <https://sacjforum.org/sites/default/files/reports/files/2020/Namibia%202005%20SAKALA%20EL%2C%20CJ.pdf>
European Convention on Human Rights, (adopted 4 November 1950, entered into force 3 September 1953) 213 UNTS 121
Federal Constitution of Malaysia 1957
Franks Van Dijk and Geoffrey Vos, 'A Method for Assessment of the Independence and Accountability of the Judiciary' [2018] 3 International Journal for Court Administration 1-21 <https://doi.org/10.18352/ijca.276>
Gabriel A Almond and Sidney Verba, The Civic Culture: Political Attitudes and Democracy in Five Nations (The Princeton University Press 1963)
Gabriel A Almond, Scott C Flanagan and Robert J Mundt (eds), Crisis, Choice, and Change: Historical Studies of Political Development (Little, Brown and Company 1973) <https://archive.org/details/crisischoicechan00almo>
George Thomas Kurian, Encyclopaedia of the World's Nations and Cultures (Infobase Publishing 2007)
Government Proceedings Act 1956
H P Lee, 'A Fragile Bastion under Siege: The 1988 Convulsion in the Malaysian Judiciary' (1990) 17 Melbourne University Law Review 386-417 <https://classic.austlii.edu.au/au/journals/MelbULawRw/1990/2.html>
Harold J Laski, A Grammar of Politics (George Allen & Unwin 1925) <https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.30187>
Harold J Laski, An Introduction to Politics (George Allen & Unwin 1931) 55
Harold J Laski, Authority in the Modern State (Yale University Press 1919) <https://archive.org/details/authorityinmoder00laskuoft>
HL Pohlman (ed), Political Thought and the American Judiciary (University of Massachusetts Press 1993); See also, Steven Foster, The Judiciary, Civil Liberties and Human Rights (De Gruyter 2006) <https://doi.org/10.1515/9780748626670>
HP Lee and V Morabito, 'Removal of Judges: The Australian Experience' (1992) Singapore Journal of Legal Studies 40-56
Hugh Corder (ed), Democracy and the Judiciary (Institute for a Democratic Alternative for South Africa 1989) <https://archive.org/details/democracyjudicia0000hugh>
International Bar Association, 'The IBA Minimum Standards of Judicial Independence' (1982) para 8 <https://www.ibanet.org/MediaHandler?id=bb019013-52b1-427c-ad25-a6409b49fe29>
International Commission of Jurists, 'Montreal Universal Declaration on the Independence Of Justice' (1983) https://www.icj.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/Montreal-Declaration.pdf
International Convention for the Protection of All Persons from Enforced Disappearance (adopted 20 December 2006, entered into force 23 December 2010) 2716 UNTS 3
International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of Their Families, (adopted 18 December 1990) UNGA Res 45/158
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (adopted 16 December 1966, entered into force 23 March 1976) 999 UNTS 171 (ICCPR)
Jon Elster and Rune Slagstad (eds), Constitutionalism and Democracy (Cambridge University Press 1988) <https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9781139173629>
Jose Maria Maravall and Adam Przeworski (eds), Democracy and the Rule of Law (Cambridge University Press 2003) <https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511610066>; Mortimer Sellers, 'An Introduction to the Rule of Law in Comparative Perspective' in Mortimer Sellers and Tadeusz Tomaszewski (eds), The Rule of Law in Comparative Perspectives (Springer 2010) 1-9 <https://doi.org/10.1007/978-90-481-3749-7_1>
Joseph Stalin, JV Stalin Work: 1907-1913, vol 2 (Foreign Languages Publishing House 1953) 375
JT Abdy and Bryan Walker, The Institutes of Justinian (Cambridge University Press 1876) <https://archive.org/details/institutesofjust00abdyuoft>
Judges (Protection) Act, 1985 (India)
Judges Code of Ethics 2009
Judges Enquiry Act 1968
Judges Enquiry Act, 1968 (India)
Judicial Accountability 1964
Judicial Officers Protection Act, 1850 (India)
Julian H Franklin (tr), On Sovereignty: Four Chapters from the Six Books of the Commonwealth by Jean Bodin (Cambridge University Press 1992)
Latimer House Principles and Guidelines 1988
Law Commission of India, '195th Report on the Judges (Inquiry) Bill 2005' (2006) 358 <http://www.commonlii.org/in/other/lawreform/INLC/2006/1.html>
Luis Fernando Barzotto, 'The Rule of Law: Contribution to a Theory of Legality' [2007] 2 Direito GV Law Review 219-260; Dan R Meagher, 'The Principle of Legality and a Common Law Bill of Rights: Clear Statement Rules Head Down Under' (2015) <https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2712334
Malaysian Bar, 'Report of the Panel of Eminent Persons to Review the 1988 Judicial Crisis in Malaysia' (2008) <https://www.malaysianbar.org.my/cms/upload_files/document/PanelofEminentPersonsReport.pdf>
Marbury v Madison, 5 United States 137 (1803) (SC)
Mark Elliott, 'The Rule of Law and Access to Justice: Some Home Truths' (2018) 77 The Cambridge Law Journal 5-8 <https://doi.org/10.1017/S0008197318000132>
Marvin Comisky and Philip C Patterson, The Judiciary: Selection, Compensation, Ethics, and Discipline (Praeger 1987)
Marzena Kordela, 'The Principle of Legal Certainty as a Fundamental Element of the Formal Concept of the Rule of Law' (2008) 110 Revue de Notariat 587-605 <https://doi.org/10.7202/1045553ar>; Lei Lei 'Legal Methods, Legal Certainty and the Rule of Law' (2017) 5 Renmin Chinese Law Review 25-57 <https://doi.org/10.4337/9781788110501.00006>
Mauro Cappelletti, '"Who Watches the Watchmen?" A Comparative Study on Judicial Responsibility' (1983) 31 The Aemerican Journal of Comparative Law 1-62 <https://doi.org/10.2307/839606>
MH McLelland, 'Disciplining Australian Judges' (1991) 17 Commonwealth Law Bulletin 675-690 <https://doi.org/10.1080/03050718.1991.9986134>
Michael Robertson, 'The Participation of Judges in the Present Legal System' in Hugh Corder (ed), Democracy and the Judiciary (Institute for Democratic Alternatives in South Africa 1989) 67-76
Mohammad Reza Vijeh, 'Equality: The Basis of Rule of Law and Peace' (2015) 10 Human Rights 92-108
NA Palkhivala, Our Constitution Defaced and Defiled (The Macmillan Company of India Ltd 1960)
Pengarah Tanah Dan Galian, Wilayah Persekutuan v Sri Lempah Enterprise Sdn Bhd [1979] 1 Malayan Law Journal 135 (FC)
Preble Stolz, Judging Judges : The Investigation of Rose Bird and the California Supreme Court (Collier Macmillan Publishers 1981) <https://archive.org/details/judgingjudgesinv0000stol>
Press Information Bureau, Government of India, Ministry of Law and Justice, 'Speedy Disposal of the Cases' (15 March 2022) <https://pib.gov.in/newsite/PrintRelease.aspx?relid=233889>.
Protocol to the African Charter on Human and People's Rights on the Establishment of an African Court on Human and People's Rights (9 June 1998, entered into force 25 January 2004) OAU Doc OAU/LEG/EXP/AFCHPR/PROT (III)
Ranganathananda Swami, Eternal Values for a Changing Society (Advaita Ashrama 1958) <https://archive.org/details/dli.ernet.504839>
RK Gooch, 'Book Review: Political Power and the Government Process by Karl Loewenstein' (1958) 20 Journal of Politics 570-571 <https://doi.org/10.1017/S0022381600033880>
Semenyih Jaya Sdn Bhd v Pentadbir Tanah Daerah Hulu Langat (2017) 4 All Malaysia Reports 123 (FC)
Sheldon Goldman, 'Judicial Selection and the Qualities That Make a "Good" Judge' (1982) 462 Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 112-124 <https://doi.org/10.1177/0002716282462001010>
Shimon Shetreet, 'The Limits of Judicial Accountability: A Hard Look at the Judicial Officers Act 1986' (1987) 10 University of New South Wales Law Journal 4-16, 11 <https://www.unswlawjournal.unsw.edu.au/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/10-1-17.pdf>
State of Maharashtra v Champa Lal 1981 All India Reporter 1675, 1982 Supreme Court Reports (1) 299 (SC)
Steve Hoadley, 'Book Review: Comparative Politics: A Developmental Approach by Gabriel A Almond and G Bingham Powell Jr (Boston: Little, Brown and Company, 1966, 348 pp)' (1969) 63 American Political Science Review 536-537 <https://doi.org/10.2307/1954710>
Steven Kay, 'Rule of Power or Rule of Law' (2007) 13 UCL Jurisprudence Review 149-156
Sub-Committee on Judicial Accountability vs Union of India [1992] All India Reporter 320, [1991] Supreme Court Reports Supplementary (2) 1 (SC)
Subordinate Courts Act 1948
Sunil Batra v Delhi Administration 1980 All India Reporter 1579, 1980 Supreme Court Reports (2) 557 (SC)
Thomas J Noonan Jr and Kenneth J Winston (eds), The Responsible Judge: Readings in Judicial Ethics (Praeger 1993)
TN Chaturvedi (ed), Administrative Accountability (Indian Institute of Public Administration 1984) <https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.274786>
United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, (adopted 13 December 2006, entered into force 3 May 2008) 2515 UNTS 3
United Nations General Assembly Resolution 67/1 (24 September 2012) <https://undocs.org/A/RES/67/1>
United Nationsl General Assembly Resolution 67/1, UN Doc A/RES/67/1
Universal Declaration of Human Rights (adopted 10 December 1948) UNGA Res 217 A(III) (UDHR)
V Subramaniam, 'Public Accountability: Context, Career and Confusions of a Concept' (1983) 29 Indian Journal of Public Administration 446-456 <https://doi.org/10.1177/0019556119830302>
William Cyrus Sprague, Griffith Ogden Ellis, Clarence B Kelland, Walter K Towers and Frederick R Austin, The Law Student's Helper, vol 15 (Nabu Press 2012)